click zoom to display a high-res image
Property Location
Property Features
A castle-like, wooden Gothic Revival gatehouse, built in 1897, marks the entrance to Milwaukee's oldest remaining Roman Catholic cemetery. Stepped gables, crenelated parapets, and denticulated cornices give the building a sense of upright angularity. But a subtler curvilinear motif softens the structure, in the parapets and Palladian window, and culminating in the gatehouse's round-arched entranceway.
Inside, are seventy-five acres of park-like rolling hills and mature trees, planned according to the romantic ideals of nineteenth-century landscape design. Like nearby Forest Hills Cemetery, it served as a popular picnic spot before the establishment of city parks in the 1890s. The stone monuments scattered throughout comprise one of the state's best collections of nineteenth-century funerary art. Many of Milwaukee's early civic leaders are buried here, their tombs often marked by handsome monuments, such as the pyramidal mausoleum for druggist Lawrence McMahon and his wife.
An exquisite brick Romanesque Revival chapel tops "Jesuit Hill," a grassy knoll rising a hundred feet above the surrounding terrain. Crypts beneath the chapel were reserved for important Roman Catholic clergy, but only one burial ever took place there. Instead, local Catholic clergy were interred on the hillsides around the chapel, giving Jesuit Hill its name. The chapel's dignified octagonal tower is the cemetery’s focal point. Both the gatehouse and chapel were designed by Erhard Brielmaier, who designed St. Josaphat’s Basilica and whose firm designed more than eight hundred churches nationwide between 1880 and 1920.
(The following information, including any bibliographic entries [see above], was taken directly from the Determination of Eligibility for Calvary Cemetery, prepared in 2013 by Mead & Hunt, Madison.)
The Romanesque-style chapel, completed in 1899, replaced the large wooden cross that originally sat at the top of Chapel Hill. Designed by Erhard Brielmaier & Sons, the completion of the interior of the chapel went slowly, so the chapel was not opened and consecrated until 1902. The chapel has a cruciform plan, rests on a square base of raised limestone, and is constructed of Cream City brick. Three smaller domes on the east, north, and south support a large, eight-sided dome at the center of the building. The main (west) entrance is covered by a large arched brick pediment supported by two limestone columns. The original door has been replaced by wood and a vinyl replacement to prevent vandalism. A large rose window is centered above the door. At the rear (north) of the building there was a large door for bringing in caskets, but is has since been enclosed by concrete block. The original glass from the windows and doors has been removed or broken due to the abandonment of the chapel sometime in the 1950s, as well as vandalism. Side windows have been blocked by wood. It is reported that the original windows were clear and not stained glass.
The original interior was reported to be quite plain with no other decorations on the walls. There are two side alters, and a raised alter at the center. All three areas have the original carved wood alters intact. The raised alter also retains its original, wrought iron gate with a flour motif. Below, 27 vaults were built for the burial of Catholic clergy, but only one was ever used, for Father Aegidius Tarasiewicz.
National And State Register Of Historic Places Listings
HI53168
Architecture & History Inventory
The Wisconsin Architecture and History Inventory (AHI) is a digital source of information on historic buildings, structures, and objects that have been surveyed by the State Historic Preservation Office in Wisconsin. Each property has a digital record providing basic information about the property and images.
Questions?
Wondering about if your property is eligible or notice some information on this property needs to be updated, reach out today!
Email UsAttribution
For a credit line: Wisconsin Historical Society, Creator, Title, Unique Identifier.
The Unique Identifier can be found at the top or bottom of the page for each item. The name of a downloaded file is NOT the unique identifier.
For bibliographic citations please consult the UW-Madison Libraries Citation Research Guide to ensure compliance with appropriate style guidelines.
Access Property Records
Some properties have more materials (correspondence, clippings, historical information, etc.) not in the digital record. If a 'Site File' exists, it's noted in the 'Additional Comments' field. Contact us for an appointment to view these materials.




